top of page
Search

SLCVO Blog 25 September

joford4
10 minutes ago
6 min read

This week's blog looks at the practical steps involved in setting up a community organisation. While each structure has its own requirements, the process is largely the same regardless of whether you choose a SCIO, CIC, Company Limited by Guarantee, Co-operative or Unincorporated Association.

 


Step 1: Start With Purpose, Not Paperwork

One of the most common mistakes new groups make is focusing on legal structures too early. Before you think about constitutions, regulators, or registration forms, spend time agreeing exactly what you're trying to achieve.

 

Ask yourselves:

  • What problem or need are we addressing?

  • Who will benefit?

  • What activities will we deliver?

  • How will those activities create a positive impact?

  • What changes do we hope to see as a result?

 

If your group cannot clearly answer these questions, it's worth taking more time to develop your ideas before choosing a structure.

 

A strong sense of purpose will make every decision afterwards much easier.

 

Step 2: Build a Strong Leadership Team

No organisation succeeds because of paperwork alone. It succeeds because good people are willing to take responsibility for guiding and governing it.

 

Depending on the structure you choose, these people may be known as:

  • Trustees

  • Directors

  • Committee Members

  • Management Committee Members

 

Whatever title they hold, they will be responsible for ensuring the organisation is well run, legally compliant, financially sustainable, and focused on its purpose.

 

The most effective leadership teams bring together a mix of skills, experience, local knowledge, and passion for the cause.

 

Trustees: The Backbone of Charitable Organisations

If your organisation is becoming a charity, you'll need trustees. Most charities appoint at least three trustees, although many choose to have more to ensure a wider range of perspectives and expertise.

 

Trustees are responsible for the overall governance of the organisation and have important legal duties under Scottish charity law. They must:

  • Act in the charity's best interests

  • Ensure resources are used responsibly

  • Comply with charity law

  • Manage conflicts of interest appropriately

  • Work collectively in support of the charity's purposes

 

When recruiting trustees, think about individuals who can bring expertise in areas such as:

  • Finance

  • Governance

  • Community engagement

  • Project management

  • Communications

  • Knowledge of the issues your organisation is addressing

 

Taking time to recruit the right trustees at the start can create a strong foundation that supports your organisation for years to come.

 

For more information, see OSCR's guidance on charity trustees:

 

Directors: Leading Social Enterprises and Companies

If you're establishing a Community Interest Company (CIC) or Company Limited by Guarantee, you'll need directors.

 

While a CIC can legally operate with a single director, having several directors is generally considered good practice as it provides a broader range of skills and improves accountability.

 

Directors have legal responsibilities under the Companies Act 2006 and must:

  • Act within their powers

  • Exercise reasonable care and skill

  • Promote the success of the organisation

  • Manage conflicts of interest

  • Ensure reporting obligations are met

 

When recruiting directors, look for skills such as:

  • Finance

  • Business planning

  • Governance

  • Marketing

  • Community engagement

  • Project management

  • Employment matters

 

Before accepting the role, directors should understand both the responsibilities involved and the commitment required.

 

You can find further guidance here:

 

Committee Members: Leading Unincorporated Associations

If your group chooses to operate as an unincorporated association, the organisation will normally be governed by a management committee or committee members rather than trustees or directors.

 

Although the title may be different, the responsibilities are very similar. Committee members are responsible for overseeing the organisation, making decisions on behalf of the membership, managing finances, ensuring activities are delivered safely and effectively, and helping the organisation achieve its aims.

 

When recruiting committee members, it is helpful to seek the same range of skills and experience that would be valuable for trustees or directors, including:

  • Finance and budgeting

  • Governance and leadership

  • Community engagement

  • Project management

  • Marketing and communications

  • Business planning and organisational development

 

As with trustees and directors, committee members should understand the responsibilities involved and be willing to act in the best interests of the organisation. A committee made up of people with diverse skills, knowledge and local experience can provide a strong foundation for any community group and help ensure it remains effective, accountable and sustainable

 

Step 3: Choose the Right Legal Structure

Once you have a clear purpose and a leadership team in place, you can choose the legal structure that best fits your organisation.

 

There is no single "best" option. The right structure will depend on your organisation's aims, planned activities, appetite for risk, funding requirements, and whether you intend to employ staff, own assets, or trade.

 

The most common structures for community organisations are:

  • Unincorporated Association

  • Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation (SCIO)

  • Community Interest Company (CIC)

  • Company Limited by Guarantee (CLG)

  • Co-operative or Community Benefit Society

 

Each structure has different advantages, responsibilities, governance requirements, and reporting obligations. For a detailed comparison of these structures, including their benefits, limitations, legal responsibilities, and when each is most appropriate, see our Blog Choosing the Right Legal Structure for Your Community Organisation  

 

The important thing is to choose the structure that supports your objectives and future plans, rather than selecting a structure first and trying to make your activities fit around it.

 

Step 4: Create Your Governing Document

Every organisation needs a rulebook. Depending on your chosen structure, this may be called a:

  • Constitution

  • Articles of Association

  • Society Rules

 

Regardless of the name, the purpose is the same. Your governing document sets out how the organisation operates, how decisions are made, who is responsible for governance, and what happens if the organisation closes.


A governing document should typically cover:

  • Purpose and objectives

  • Membership arrangements

  • Governance arrangements

  • Meetings and decision-making processes

  • Financial procedures

  • Procedures for dissolution or winding up

 

Think of it as the foundation on which your organisation will operate. Taking the time to get it right at the beginning can prevent governance issues and disputes later on.

 

SCVO has an excellent range of guidance, templates and model governing documents to help groups develop a constitution or other governing document appropriate to their chosen structure. Their resources include advice on drafting constitutions as well as downloadable model documents that can be adapted to meet local needs.

 

Helpful resources include:

How to Write Your Constitution

SCVO Model Constitutions

 

If you're unsure where to start, SLCVO can also provide support and guidance to help your group develop or review a governing document, ensuring it is fit for purpose and meets the requirements of your chosen legal structure.

 

Step 5: Register With the Appropriate Regulator

Once your governing document is complete, you'll need to register with the relevant regulator for your chosen structure.

 

 

The application processes vary, most registrations will require similar information, including:

  • Your governing document

  • Details of trustees, directors, or committee members

  • A description of your activities

  • Information about who will benefit

  • Basic financial information and projected income

 

Before submitting an application, it is worth reviewing the guidance provided by the relevant regulator to ensure your application meets all requirements. SLCVO can also provide support throughout the registration process, helping groups understand what information is needed and preparing the documentation required for submission.

 

Step 6: Open for Business

Registration is an important milestone, but organisations will also need to:

  • Open a bank account

  • Arrange appropriate insurance

  • Develop key policies and procedures

  • Register with HMRC where necessary

  • Establish financial controls


Final Thoughts

When people start discussing a new community initiative, the conversation often jumps straight to questions like:

  • "Should we become a SCIO?"

  • "Would a CIC be better?"

  • "Do we need a company?"

In reality, these questions should come later.

 

The strongest organisations begin by understanding a community need, identifying who will benefit, agreeing their purpose, and building a committed leadership team. Once those foundations are in place, choosing the right legal structure becomes much clearer.

 

Next week's blog is the final in our learning mini-series and will explore the key policies. procedures, and governance arrangements community organisations should have in place to manage risk, meet their legal responsibilities, and operate effectively from day one.

 

If you would like to discuss the support we provide to start-up groups email

 

Blog produced with the support of Microsoft Copilot

 

Comments

© 2023 by THE HOPE CENTER. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page